By linking important feminist theoretical debates with case studies, naples illustrates the. Davis and craven chapter 1 what is the\feminist in. One of the difficult things about defining feminist ethnography is that in practice, the forms of feminist ethnography are nearly as diverse as feminist ethnographers themselves. Various forms of critical ethnography might thus productively be read as feminist ethnography. It is that promise and hope that i want to share with you in this book, with everybody. It was the time when there was a need to challenge the positivist dominated research practice.
Recent texts which fall under this rubric rely on unexamin. The purpose of this study was to explore the perspectives of women diagnosed with cooccurring disorders on the treatments provided by a state psychiatric hospital so that appropriate recommendations for changes in treatment may be made. A critical black feminist ethnography of treatment for women with cooccurring disorders in the psychiatric hospital. As a means of gauging the historical production of feminist ethnographic texts, i propose to examine four time. It serves as a critical dialog about the possibilities for feminist ethnography in the 21st centuryat the intersection of engaged feminist research and collective activism. Feminist theory first developed in the 1970s as result of profound changes in womens experiences and situations that led to a political movement. An introduction to definition and method 5 context auto ethnography was used to challenge hegemonic discourses and therefore, validates the experiences of others whatever these may be. Judith stacey, can there be a feminist ethnography. Although feminist ethnography is an emerging genre. View feminist ethnography research papers on academia. What sets this work apart from other selfreflexive feminist ethnographies is its rigorous engagement with the concrete inequalities, refusals, and misunderstandings between the author and the women she worked with in india.
All feminist theory has been concerned in divergent ways and through divergent means with establishing the subjectposition of women. Feminist ethnography second semester, 2009 2 credits prof. Feminist ethnographers in the 1960s and 1970s sought to correct a male bias in the discipline and promoted the study of women. Simultaneously, feminist anthropology challenges essentialist feminist theories developed in europe and america. This article explores the relevance of the ethnographic study of the internet for feminist scholars interested in families. Feminist critiques of representing others in their recent edited volume. Fictions of feminist ethnography is an ambitious, experimental, comprehensive and learned book directed at a professional anthropological audience.
This general overview will show a gradual shift from an obvious con. In the process of reflecting on the nature of anthropology itself visweswaran devises an experimental approach to writing feminist ethnography. A critical black feminist ethnography of treatment for. Recent texts that fall under this rubric rely on unexamined notions of. Womens studies international forum 111, 1988 lila abulughod, can there be a feminist ethnography. Ethnography is one of the chief research methods in sociology, anthropology and other cognate disciplines in the social sciences. The proliferation of cybercommunities and computermediated. The remaining chapters examine various methods and forms of knowledge production associated with feminist ethnography. Critical ethnography was used and the data was viewed through the lens of intersectionality from the black feminist perspective. They engage multiple perspectives and unpack deep theoretical, methodological, and political material in an accessible and transparent way. When governments take an interest in feminist ethnography. There is no original or primary gender a drag imitates, but gender is a kind of. Example methods methodology philosophy guiding principles lynn rollison, rn, bsn, ma, phdc what it is how it has been utilized to study people ethnography hallmarks of ethnography outsider ethnography insider ethnography feminist ethnography.
Feminist theory defined the term feminist theory is used to refer to a multitude of types of works, produced by a movement of activists and scholars in a variety of disciplines chafetz, 1997. Recent texts which fall under this rubric rely on unexamined notions of sisterhood and the recovery of lost voices. Jennifer mannings photo jennifer manning, phd student dublin institute of technology, ireland jennifer. This is not to say that feminist ethnographies do not share many things, but that the kinds of ethnographies feminists write reflect. This handbook provides an unparalleled, critical guide to its principles and practice. Davis and craven highlight methods involving participatory action and political activism. Although feminist ethnography is an emerging genre, the question of what the term means remains open. In the first period 18801920, biological sex was seen to determine social roles, and gender was not seen as separable from sex, though it was beginning to emerge as an analytical category.
An ethnography of wall street karen ho kang builds upon feminist sociologist arlie hochschilds concept of the second shift, and naomi wolfs. It is perhaps best to define ethnography in terms of its attributes, functionality as well as the description of its processes carried out in the field. Though the phrase feminist ethnography emerged only in the late 1980s, the discipline had existed long before then. Davis and craven chapter 1 what is the\feminist in feminlst ethnography 9 ll what is feminist ethnography i a common question about feminist. Writing in the wake of neoliberalism, where human rights and social justice have increasingly been subordinated to proliferating consumer choices and ideals of market justice, contributors to this collection argue that feminist ethnographers are in a key position to reassert the central feminist connections between theory, methods, and activism. The methodological imperatives of feminist ethnography. Fictions of feminist ethnography kamala visweswaran published by university of minnesota press visweswaran, kamala. The 2016 2017 gwss colloquium series presents feminist ethnographies. Jan 9 introduction to feminist ethnography read for first class on ereserve. For them, feminist ethnography can be characterized as a feminist sensibility, a commitment to paying attention to marginality and power differentials. Despite these earlier studies made on womens experiences, feminist ethnography only emerged as a recognized method of inquiry in the 1960s and 1970s because of the growing feminist movements. Feminist ethnography and art practices by south asian women share a common base of fighting, resisting and dissenting against all forms of patriarchal domination, from the domains of the family to. In conclusion, i will agree with coleman 2010, that given the complex and variable meaning of cyber cultures, longterm ethnographic research is well suited to.
I find the book thoughtprovoking and highly recommendable because of the sensitive, critical and sometimes even surprisingly innovative handling of. This collection reengages 20th century debates on feminist ethnography in a 21st century context. I am going to discuss the development of feminist theories as to the sources of gender inequality and its pervasiveness, and the different feminist political solutions and. A conclusion summarizes the main arguments and highlights their theoretical and political implications. She sees me and all her daughters we are six living better lives because of feminist politics. The five presenters were concerned with the writing of ethnography, particularly in terms of the. This volume moves the field of chicana feminist theory forward by examining feminist creative expression, the politics of representation, and the realities of chicana life. Kamala viswesweran discusses what feminist anthropologists and experimental ethnographers can learn from each other, and proposes new avenues for feminist ethnography. Participant observation and feminist critiques of ethnography.
I read a few of the chapters of this book for a course, and later in preparing for my own ethnographic work. At its most fundamental level, feminist ethnography is a qualitative research methodology emerging out of anthropology a discipline that. Chicana feminisms presents new essays on chicana feminist thought by scholars, creative writers, and artists. Fictions of feminist ethnography by kamala visweswaran. Davis and craven divide the book into eight chapters, the first of which offers a brief historicization of feminism s waves, as well as an overview of ethnographic methods. Feminist ethnography ghosh major reference works wiley. The first systematically locates ethnography firmly in its relevant historical and intellectual contexts. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. In these essays about her work with women in southern india, kamala visweswaran addresses such troubled issues. The black womanistfeminism or black feminist thought movement comes out of the feminist movement of the 1970s and is a direct interface with the civil rights movement, as it recognizes that women of african descent in the u. The online world is an emerging field site for feminist scholars investigating spousal, parental, and kin relations, one that opens up new arenas of study but also requires novel methodological approaches.
Introduction to feminist theory university of pittsburgh. Histories of feminist ethnography kamala visweswaran. Pdf constructing a postcolonial feminist ethnography. Bulgaria ethnographic intelligence feminist anthropology feminist methods. To say that a woman is a human being is to disentangle her from the dangerous nexus of objectifi. The feminist practice of ethnography sage research methods. Rush, autumn grubbswetnam, and christina lane the focus of this chapter is the ways in which communication theory and method can provide a richer, more complex and enlightening canvas of. Naples draws on different research topics, such as welfare, poverty, sexual identity, and sexual abuse, to illustrate some of the most salient dilemmas of feminist research. Race, gender, and the body in beauty service work liquidated.
The variety of feminisms and their contribution to gender. Feminist activist ethnography provides a crucial road map for activist anthropologists, demonstrating how historical feminist ethnography shapes where we have been, where we are now, and where we are going, whether postneoliberal or notsopostneoliberal. Womens struggle for recognition continues in sociology. As a means of gauging the historical production of feminist ethnographic texts, i propose to examine four time periods. With this text, davis and craven have crafted a stunningly multidimensional, textured, provocative, and vibrant introduction to feminist ethnography. A feminist ethnography of an all girls afterschool club by alison anne happel the institution of schooling is one of the most formative spaces in which young people learn about gender norms and expectations. Rather, there have been evolutions of the different frameworks under the broad heading of feminist theory since the late 1700s.
The genesis of feminist thought in anthropology has been discursively embedded in the wider field of academic feminism and anthropological theory formation. They also emphasize the creative potential of feminist knowledge production through visual art, film, poetry, or fiction. Define and critically read feminist theory compare, contrast, and critique various perspectives of feminist theorists explain feminist epistemology and critically analyze the ways in which knowledge is produced use feminist approaches to theory to think systematically about power and. Fictions of feminist ethnography university of minnesota. Womens life stories and reciprocal ethnography as feminist and. Defining ethnography ethnography is defined in many ways and there seems to be no single definition of what it really is. The masking of subversion in ethnographic description in clifford, james and marcus, george, eds, writing culture. Can there be a feminist ethnography crapanzano, vincent 1986. Feminism is the doctrine advocating social, political, and economic rights for. The variety of feminisms and their contribution to gender equality introduction my focus is the continuities and discontinuities in recent feminist ideas and perspectives. I argue that this set of imperatives enables feminist ethnographers to successfully navigate the challenges they face. At its most fundamental level, feminist ethnography is a qualitative.
189 388 1174 1142 719 834 995 1584 1391 277 1452 1355 1228 595 400 250 725 1338 1030 110 1551 1540 92 1074 199 979 143 446 540 875 1284 298 510 1037 1097 748 208 262 744 253 914 579 443 1001